Revamping Law by Circumventing the State. Non-governmental organizations in the international management of social violence on the African continent
Promouvoir l'Etat de droit en contournant l'Etat. Organisations non gouvernementales internationales et gestion de la violence sociétale dans le Sud africain
Résumé
This thesis explores the social usages of the law in scholarly and professional spaces,
in the North, that are sites of production and legitimation of tools devised to diagnose and
prescribe solutions over armed conflicts on the African continent since the end of the Cold
war. Based on the hypothesis of the “weak” character of an internationalized space of conflict
management, it aims at tracing the triggers and logic of a “sens commun réformateur” over
armed conflicts in the South, expressed in a three-pronged emphasis over prevention,
pacification and punishment.
It favors an empirical entry, the usages of the law by non-governmental organizations
based in the United States and Western Europe. Its focus is restricted to social usages of the
law ranging from the legitimation of military interventions to para-judicial tools such as
“Alternative dispute resolution” to judicial international arenas.
Divided in three parts, it traces firstly, the genesis and turn, expressed in policy and
scholarly discourses and practices, towards a political economy of intervention, justified as
triggered by the diagnosed failure of the recipient State in the African South, and articulated
with a redefinition of intervention as a continuum ranging from prevention to military
interventions. It shows, secondly, how non-governmental forms of intervention have been
integrated within this redefinition of intervention as a modality not only of circumventing
recipient States, but also of rebuilding social peace in the South, i.e. of building a “bottom up”
State, and analyzes the redefinition of forms of legitimation of non-profit modalities of
interventionism. It explores, thirdly, the instrumental role played by the law as a symbolic
capital and a moral resource in accommodating a tension between constraint, including in the
moral and legal arsenal deployed to justify military interventions, and order, in that the effect
is one of legitimation within objectified legal hierarchies.
La thèse examine les « laboratoires » africains de ré-enchantement du rapport entre le Nord et les suds africains par un interventionnisme redéfini comme un continuum entre une approche économique des violences armées enracinée dans le tournant néolibéral des années 1980, et leur criminalisation.